Why the Conservatives should not vote against the cut to the Winter Fuel Payment

One of the first Parliamentary tests that Keir Starmer’s Government could face is a possible Parliamentary vote on the abolition of the Winter Fuel Payment. That would be a test of the loyalty of his backbenchers suddenly facing the reality of the tough decisions which governments have to take.

But it would also be a test for the Conservative Opposition. Rishi Sunak has tabled a motion that the statutory instrument delivering the cut should be annulled. That opens up important questions for the party going forward.

One theme running through much comment on this website since the election has been the importance of Conservatives being an effective Opposition. Tabling this motion could be seen as a vivid example of that.

The Conservatives have acted nimbly after the government tabled the Statutory Instrument only last Thursday and have got ahead of the LibDems. There is a legitimate argument as well that this is an important measure that deserves Parliamentary scrutiny and this motion is one way to try to secure that.

Discover David Willetts' Work

Explore more of David's work and learn more about his professional career.